All 4 'Martha’s Vineyard Mystery' Movies in Order (2024)

The Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries is a Hallmark murder mystery on the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries channel. The movie series first aired in January 2020. Movies are based on the novels by Philip R. Craig. What makes this series even more unique, is that Craig’s son, a sergeant in the Edgartown Police Department, helps the production to make the movies as realistic as possible.

The movie series follows a retired Boston detective who returns to his hometown in Massachusetts and becomes involved in various criminal investigations. In these adventures, he is accompanied by his old flame, the local doctor and medical examiner. The stories are intertwined with events from the past that haunt the retired cop.

How many Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies are there?

There are four movies in this murder mystery series. The first entry in the series aired in 2020, and the most recent episode came out the following year, 2021.

Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies in order (at a glance)

Martha’s Vineyard Mystery seems to be a Hallmark project that stands out. There are countless wonderful mystery movies and TV series, but Martha’s Vineyard Mystery has it all. A good source material plots points that keep you guessing, and beautiful scenery to encompass it all. Here are all four movies at a glance:

  1. A Beautiful Place to Die(2020)
  2. Riddled with Deceit(2020)
  3. Ships in the Night(2021)
  4. Poisoned in Paradise(2021)

This movie series has two leads, Jesse Metcalfe as Jeff Jackson, and Sarah Lind as Zee Madieras. Other notable actors in Martha’s Vineyard Mystery are Eric Keenleyside as the chief of police, Chelsea Hobbs as the local reporter, and Sunita Prasad as the local hotel manager.

Are Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies connected?

Yes, Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies are connected. All entries to the series, have the same premise, they revolve around a crime that has been committed. Some other notable plots that take place during the whole movie series are the romantic subplot between our leads and the haunting of Jackson’s past in Boston.

Do you need to watch Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies in a specific order?

There is no specific order in which you should enjoy this movie series, watching it by the release date is perfect for maximum enjoyment.

What is the best way to watch Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies?

The best way to watch Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies is by release date. Some plot points are prolonged through a few consecutive episodes.

Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies in order (by release date)

1. A Beautiful Place to Die(2020)

All 4 'Martha’s Vineyard Mystery' Movies in Order (1)

Director: Mark Jean
Release date: January 12, 2020
Runtime: 1h 25min

Synopsis: An early retirement from the Boston PD forces young Jeff Jackson to start a new chapter of his life in his father’s house at Martha’s Vineyard. But, trouble is never far away. One day, Jackson discovers a murdered dead body of a young man, Ray Norris. He calls the police and one thing leads to another and the ex-cop is invited to consult on the case. While investigating, he meets his old flame, Dr. Zee Madieras, who is the chief medical examiner, and they decide to unite their forces to find the truth faster.

2. Riddled with Deceit(2020)

All 4 'Martha’s Vineyard Mystery' Movies in Order (2)

Director: Andy Mikita
Release date: February 23, 2020
Runtime: 1h 25min

Synopsis: Jackson and Dr. Zee’s friend is in trouble. Her brooch worth $5 million has been returned after sixty years. But, not for long. Now, there is a thief and a murderer on the loose. Will our duo be able to figure out who is behind all of this?

RELATED:All 7 Mystery 101 Movies in Order

3. Ships in the Night(2021)

All 4 'Martha’s Vineyard Mystery' Movies in Order (3)

Director: Mark Jean
Release date: January 17, 2021
Runtime: 1h 24min

Synopsis: A local art gallery organizes a fundraiser, but the event never says the light of day. On the night before the fundraiser, a robbery takes place that claims the lives of two community members. The police are getting nowhere with the case, so our leads have to take charge once again.

4. Poisoned in Paradise(2021)

All 4 'Martha’s Vineyard Mystery' Movies in Order (4)

Director: Mark Jean
Release date: May 16, 2021
Runtime: 1h 24min

Synopsis: The former detective Jeff and the resident Zee, finally reignite their former flame after working so closely together. When one thing goes right, many other things go wrong. A local waitress approaches Jeff and explains all her problems to him. He advises her to get help from the police, but it was no help and the next day Katie turns up dead. Our main protagonist feels very guilty because he didn’t help her in time so he takes on the investigation with Chief Madeiras to find out who is behind this death.

Where to watch Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies?

Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies can be caught on the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries channel. If you miss it there, you can find them, free for everyone with a cable TV log-in, on Hallmark Channel Everywhere. The third option is to rent or purchase all three movies on Amazon.

Will there be more Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies?

At this time there is one more installment of Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies in production. The movie is titled American Dreamer, and it is commissioned for 2022. But, the fate of most Hallmark mystery series is up in the air. In conclusion, we still don’t know if a new movie is coming or Martha’s Vineyard Mystery movies series has been canceled.

All 4 'Martha’s Vineyard Mystery' Movies in Order (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kieth Sipes

Last Updated:

Views: 6595

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kieth Sipes

Birthday: 2001-04-14

Address: Suite 492 62479 Champlin Loop, South Catrice, MS 57271

Phone: +9663362133320

Job: District Sales Analyst

Hobby: Digital arts, Dance, Ghost hunting, Worldbuilding, Kayaking, Table tennis, 3D printing

Introduction: My name is Kieth Sipes, I am a zany, rich, courageous, powerful, faithful, jolly, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.